看很多消毒纸巾都是苯扎氯铵的,苯扎氯铵和酒精,哪个消灭冠状病毒效果更好?

  • 途观
    如题 感觉原先很少有酒精的消毒纸巾,最近才出来,之前都是苯扎氯铵,苯扎氯铵和酒精效果哪个更好呢?
  • D
    DTHY
    苯扎氯铵无效,酒精有效 iOS fly ~
  • j
    jinqihrb
    笑看张嘴就来系列,没有给出可靠来源的都当胡说八道。小尾巴~
  • d
    disposable
    中国国外支援的采购清单一般只推荐3种: 乙醇,次氯酸钠,过硫酸氢钾。

    苯扎氯铵对冠状病毒效果并不好。

    以前选择苯扎氯铵等表面活性剂做表面消毒湿巾的原因是价格低,刺激性小。乙醇生产/储存很麻烦,容易出安全事故,皮肤刺激性也大。
  • s
    serafim
    就是之前一些文章写的无效,害得我把免洗洗手液的都换成酒精得了,这么重要的事国家级也不出点权威的消毒手册什么的,唉 iOS fly ~
  • d
    disposable
    具体要看文献了。我会更相信酒精。
  • 暗暗一笑
    官方发布的那么多指南你们真的不看的吗?
  • m
    mongnan
    回复2#DTHY
    我去,原来没用啊,我还以为有效果,之前去国外还买了好几包,一路上擦 iOS fly ~
  • m
    mongnan
    回复4#bzerg007
    看了这个链接放心了 iOS fly ~
  • j
    jinqihrb
    当然有用,别听那些张嘴就来的,网上有很多论文,随便找一个给你

    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15923059/

    Abstract

    The recent severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) epidemic in Asia and Northern America led to broad use of various types of disinfectant in order to control the public spread of the highly contagious virus. However, only limited data were available to demonstrate their efficacy against SARS coronavirus (SARS-CoV). We therefore investigated eight disinfectants for their activity against SARS-CoV according to prEN 14476. Four hand rubs were tested at 30s (Sterillium, based on 45% iso-propanol, 30% n-propanol and 0.2% mecetronium etilsulphate; Sterillium Rub, based on 80% ethanol; Sterillium Gel, based on 85% ethanol; Sterillium Virugard, based on 95% ethanol). Three surface disinfectants were investigated at 0.5% for 30 min and 60 min (Mikrobac forte, based on benzalkonium chloride and laurylamine; Kohrsolin FF, based on benzalkonium chloride, glutaraldehyde and didecyldimonium chloride; Dismozon pur, based on magnesium monoperphthalate), and one instrument disinfectant was investigated at 4% for 15 min, 3% for 30 min and 2% for 60 min [Korsolex basic, based on glutaraldehyde and (ethylenedioxy)dimethanol]. Three types of organic load were used: 0.3% albumin, 10% fetal calf serum, and 0.3% albumin with 0.3% sheep erythrocytes. Virus titres were determined by a quantitative test (endpoint titration) in 96-well microtitre plates. With all tested preparations, SARS-CoV was inactivated to below the limit of detection (reduction factor mostly > or =4), regardless of the type of organic load. In summary, SARS-CoV can be inactivated quite easily with many commonly used disinfectants.小尾巴~
  • m
    mongnan
    回复11#jinqihrb
    谢谢啊,已经回国,不出远门应该用不上了,还是酒精喷一下方便 iOS fly ~
  • 途观
    到底有用么…